From Voting Booths to Victories: Keep Democracy Alive

Nothing happens overnight. If you are looking at the outcome of the Midterms, be assured that democracy was on the ballot even if the words were not. 

Our League has long been raising our voice, asking only that citizens be heard. That is why we helped pass Proposition 4 in 2018. We’re talking about power, something supermajorities take as a mandate to do whatever they like. That is not a representative democracy. 

The League advocates in many areas although our core mission – to defend democracy and empower voters – is always primary. Over the years our message has been on redistricting, climate change, money in politics and more - all important but complicated and challenging concepts. Now, look at Utah’s and the country’s elections and you will see the theme that stuck – representation.

In simple terms, we said:

  • Gerrymandering allows politicians to choose their voters, rather than the other way around, which distorts democratic representation.

  • We believe in representative democracy and only want our representatives to represent us.

  • We want our elected officials to listen to their constituents and respond to their needs

 
Gerrymandered districts are often non-competitive, leading to a lack of accountability for elected officials. Voter turnout tends to be lower in gerrymandered districts due to perceived lack of choice. And of course, the practice enables the manipulation of district lines to favor one party, which can disenfranchise voters.
 
The Midterms across the nation may not have been specifically motivated by gerrymandering but the winning messages were surprisingly similar. The voters want politicians to listen to them. Because of that, Utah voters successfully opposed Amendment B, which would have made citizen initiatives almost impossible to pass, So, don’t forget that the simplest message is often the most effective. 
 
You can be proud that we helped change the political environment and are continuing to fight for democracy. Since I last wrote, there have been several legal actions. 

On our blog, you can read about our case being heard again before the Utah Supreme Court, this time in opposition to the legislature’s creation of a three-judge panel.  Before we even got to court, the governor had packed the high court with three new justices – all male from Brigham Young University. While this is not illegal, it was another effort to influence the redistricting rulings that have been coming down since 2021.
 
Legislators began by sending three cases they lost to this new court. One was the Planned Parenthood case, in which we offered a friend-of-the-court brief. Our redistricting case was also heard, as was another from youths seeking redress over climate change. The justices have not yet ruled in these cases. 
 
However, our attorneys have filed a brief seeking the recusal of new Justice Michael Menssen. Before he joined the court, he had signed the petition to repeal Proposition 4 and we believe that constitutes a conflict of interest. He will have to make that decision now. 
 
In the meantime, Lt. Gov. Diedre Henderson was attempting to stave off the federal government, which was seeking Utah’s private voting records. The LWV Utah joined the ACLU to sue and on October 23, the courts dismissed the case. It was one of 28 other state cases, and the Department of Justice will not be able to refile them. 
 
Yes, a lot has been going on since 2017 when we first fought to get Proposition 4 on the ballot. We also approved a timely study of the Utah judiciary, which will help us advocate for judicial independence. This is sure to come up in the next legislative session. 
 
We hope that you will join our Legislative Action Corps to monitor and report on bills coming up. Our recent update to the Clean Energy Study, which you have received, will e an advocacy tool. With the emphasis on water, nuclear, and even data centers, this study should prove useful in the coming session. Plan on participating in our virtual Legislative Preview on Jan. 7 at 6 p.m., too. 
 
And finally, I’d like to congratulate several League members for bravely putting themselves out as candidates in this last election. Win or lose, it’s critical that we participate in our government and make our positions known. 
 
And so we continue doing what we do – standing up for democracy every day. 

In League, 

Katharine Biele, President

Next
Next

The League Goes to Court