The League Goes to Court

I'm encouraging you to listen to our redistricting case on Monday, October 5 at 10 a.m. The court will be hearing three cases including ours beginning at 9 a.m. Following is a State Court Report on our long drawn-out case - with a link to the hearing at the end. 

Can Utah Create New Judicial Panels for Constitutional Cases? — October 5

Planned Parenthood of Utah v. Stormont; League of Women Voters v. Utah State Legislature; Roberts v. Dept. of Natural Resources, Utah Supreme Court

The Utah Supreme Court will take up a state law originally passed in February that allows litigants to transfer constitutional challenges against the state from their assigned district court judge to newly created three-judge panels, randomly selected from judicial districts statewide. The legislation was enacted within months of a district court judge handing lawmakers high-profile redistricting losses. The state promptly used the law to transfer that ongoing case and others challenging Utah’s near-total abortion ban and grant of fossil-fuel permits away from their current judges. The plaintiffs in each action have sought to block the transfers before Utah’s high court. In the wake of these complaints, the legislature passed a new version of the law, in part removing an earlier restriction that only the state, not any party, could request a panel and automatically providing for a separate constitutional court to hear constitutional challenges if the panel law is invalidated.

The voting rights, abortion provider, and youth climate advocate plaintiffs make various arguments in favor of blocking the law and the transfers, including that the Utah Constitution contemplates only a limited legislative role in court administration and allows only single-judge district courts. The transfer scheme also creates an “uneven playing field” they allege, by effectively allowing a veto over a plaintiffs’ chosen venue in certain cases, violating constitutional provisions guaranteeing uniform laws and open courts. A state brief justifying the legislation, in part, as addressing “concerns about individual judges in particular districts frequently striking down laws,” climate plaintiffs add, only highlights the law’s design to permit “one-sided gamesmanship” by the state.

As State Court Report has written, the Utah law “is part of a national trend involving legislators responding to losses by changing who hears constitutional cases,” with at least seven states passing similar legislation in recent years.

Watch the arguments here.

Next
Next

Vote with Confidence in Utah!